For those unfamiliar with the expression, “C-Suite” is business slang for the exclusive gathering of chief officers within a corporation or organization. Some of these individuals literally have the word “chief” in their titles: Chief Executive Officer, Chief Operating Officer, Chief Financial Officer, Chief Information Officer.
Some entities (not many) also have a Chief Marketing Officer, under whose control the PR functions would operate. In the scheme of things, it is a relatively recent development: as far as anyone can determine, the very first person to be granted this title was Sergio Zyman, who was Chief Marketing Officer at the Coca-Cola Company from 1993 to 1998.
But within the C-Suite, the Chief Marketing Officer (or CMO for the acronym obsessed) is usually the weakest link in the executive chain. In November 2005, the CMO Council, a trade association, issued a report that exposed the problems in this C-Suite niche. The survey of 400 executives found only 10% believed their marketing groups were “highly influential and strategic” within the company. Furthermore, less than half expressed confidence that their efforts were “well regarded and respected.”
“This study confirms marketers need to move from a tactical orientation to a more analytic and strategic approach that will enable them to realign marketing initiatives with the overall corporate mission,” said Donovan Neale-May, executive director of the CMO Council, in a news release that accompanied the report.
Even more troubling is the CMOs rarely stay long in the C-Suite. A July 2004 survey from research firm Spencer Stuart found that the average tenure for chief marketing officers at the top 100 branded companies is just 23 months. In comparison, chief executive officers stay in the C-Suite, on average, 54 months.
The Spencer Stuart survey discovered that “14% of CMOs for the world’s top brands have been with their companies for more than three years — and nearly half are new to the job over the last 12 months.”
Now, the realm of CMO goes far beyond PR – it can encompass all aspects of marketing (including advertising, sales management, product development, market research, customer service and internal communications).
But that raises a question: where do PR professionals sit at the C-Suite table? The answer: they don’t. Or at least they’re not there yet.
“We hear how PR should be at the table, but I would contend most PR people are not qualified to be at the table,” says Terry Hemeyer, senior counsel at Pierpont Communications in Houston and a senior lecturer on the faculty of the University of Texas at Austin. “First, they don’t understand the business well enough. Second, they are too tactical – they are too worried about using the AP style in press releases and not about the company, its goals and its objectives.”
And herein lies the problem. PR is proactive in its promotional aspects, but too often it is reactive when it comes to the bigger picture. Namely, when it comes to the bottom line issues affecting a company or organization’s financial health, PR professionals are often clueless.
“The folks on mahogany row already nod reverently in the direction of lawyers and CPAs and other specialists,” explains Richard Barger, president of Barger Consulting. “PR pros need to figure out what keeps the boss up at night and provide objective-based, business-oriented solutions. No CEO gives a rip about whether you use a fifth color on that brochure, but they sure care about reducing turnover, increasing sales, cutting costs, improving profits, and many other business metrics.”
Barger’s advice for addressing this situation: “Become a businessperson who understands biz-com, not a communicator who is trying to communicate ‘about’ business.”
J. Brooks Christol, corporate communications specialist at Healthways in Nashville, echoes Barger’s sentiments. “It is easy to blame the woes of our industry on the C-Suite, but the truth is that we are just as much to blame as anyone,” he says. “So many people come into the industry thinking it is easy to garner press attention, that their role is to get a client in front of a reporter, do a follow-up to make sure the story runs, and then move on to the next appearance. The problem is that we don't pay attention to the details and nuances that are constantly evolving, the details that can skew the tone of the messages we're sending out.”
I embrace the opinions reflected here. PR people don’t belong in the C-Suite if all they are bringing to the table is a standard-issue PR bag of tricks. Why do so few PR people have friends in the C-Suite? Because too many PR people are, genuinely, their own worst enemies.
(Phil Hall is the former president of Open City Communications, a New York PR agency, and former editor of PR News. His latest book "The New PR" will be released later this year from Larstan Publishing.)
This is a clarion call. Mark your calendars. This is being billed as THE WEB RUMBLE OF THE DECADE! Welcome to another edition of Thunderdome.
We are please to announce the premier sporting event of the season: "Mad Keen" vs. "The Cluetrain". Is Web 2.0 tantamount to the Second Coming or is it Cultural and Economic Armageddon? Andrew Keen, author of "Cult of the Amateur," takes on the various evangelists of the seminal Web 2.0 treatise "The Cluetrain Manifesto."
WARNING: This is a no-holds-barred death match. The fight is over when one man leaves the arena.
Want to see it first hand? Well, the rolling rumble is coming to a town near you. Here's the schedule so far:
Friday, May 18 (2:30pm):PERSONAL DEMOCRACY FORUM, NYC Web 2.0: Cult of the Amateur? A Debate with Clay Shirky, Craig Newmark and Robert Scoble. Moderated by Joshua Levy.
Sunday, May 20 (5:00pm):BERKELEY CYBERSALON New Media Wars: Amateur versus Auteur. A discussion about the democratization of media with Dan Gillmor, Robert Scoble and Katie Hafner (New York Times).
Wednesday, June 6 (7:00pm):STRAND BOOKSTORE Keen debate with Lev Grossmann, Editor Time Magazine.
Tuesday, June 12 (6:30pm):DIGITAL HOLLYWOOD, Santa Monica, CA A debate with Jonathan Nelson (founder and chairman of Organic) moderated by Michael Laskoff. Presented by The Branded Asset Management Group and BAM Ventures.
Tuesday, June 19 (7:00pm):BARNES & NOBLE, CAMPBELL, CA Debate with Keith Teare, Nick Carr and Steve Gillmor. Moderated by Dan Farber of ZDNet.
On Thursday, March 8, 2007 at 7:41 AM, Ronn Torossian, President and CEO of 5WPR, emphatically promised that he was going to sue us. No real reason, he was just irritated by our teasing him about getting in bed with pornographer Joe Francis. Anyway, Ronn gave his obscenity-laced word that we'd see the complaint in 72 hours. It's now late by
Kathleen Durazo about A Measly $2.8 Million Goes Missing, Lawsuit Results Fri, Jul 31, 10:58:34 AM Ray Durazo (the founder) sold the company to Dan in 1999. He was not involved in any of this. He (and I) found out about the lawsuit in the LA Times. In addition to embezzling this m [...]