RANT: Is PR Beyond Ridicule?Comments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
That's why I went out on my own. I'd had enough of other people's morals and so called correct choices. I guess you can't BS a BS artist.
However, now that I'm on the other side, I catch grief from others, too. So I just think we're all people doing the best we can. As an independent, I feel like I can make it so long as I don't sell out. Good entry, very thought provoking.
Buck up, Amanda... They don't call it the "bleeding" edge for nothing! You are ahead of the curve in your rejection of this race to the bottom.
I've experienced the same emotions, at work and blogging lately. The future is a lonely place. While many of my past ideas have become the norm, all my latest/greatest concepts start off as foreign and too different to be accepted. This isn't surprising because in the past I've under-estimated the degree of change, while over-estimating people's ability to perceive and respond to that change. When dataesthetic.org was first founded, we saw the emerging world as an extension of industrial society, a logical next stage. Today I realize this was wrong: Network/data culture represents the greatest change in the human condition since agriculture. We came to recognize this about the same time the world came around to our previous position. On one hand this makes me seem "forward-thinking", but on the other, my repudiation and and willingness to re-evaluate makes my perspective seem wishy-washy or clouded. All you can do is keep posting about the things you see. At some point, others are bound to see things too, and then it will be old news. We can be as forward looking as we care to be, but unless someone reads or engages with the content, it just doesn't matter. Only by posting the problem on sites like Strumpette will the conversation begin, and questions be asked. For the record, shameless self-promotion isn't new, but the manner and degree we see today is unique. A recent poll showed that the majority of teens today want to be famous. Not "accomplished/famous" like athletes, politicians, movie stars and musical artists who are famous for their work, but "notorious/famous" like Paris Hilton or K-Fed, famous for their slack. It's another side of the same coin. It won't go away any time soon, of course, so I get your frustration and despair. It has become a legitimate tactic, thus it would be a disservice to clients NOT to recognize and respond to it (if not practice it!). I'm reminded of this week's Boston Legal: Alan Shore intentionally undermined a friend's remarkable recovery from Asperger's Syndrome to win a case. Yet as you noted in your earlier Ron/GGW post PR isn't the law, so it's completely fair to ask what standards we hold ourselves to. Shel noted in his week-summary post on Strumpette, PR is earned, not bought. I believe that currency is undermined much more by political PR than shameless notariety. The PR pros in the White House and Congress do violence to the national dialogue by using the tool of "the non-crisis" (I wrote an article on this issue at http://dataesthetic.org/dbdd/?p=7 ) to incite and scare voters in a particular direction. Another view of the same tumor, eating away at our culture. Many times the best parry is a joke. Ridicule the ridiculous openly and loudly, and ridiculous loses it's luster and cultural cachet. Posts like today's make the point sharply and wittily, and force readers to think. Given the number of readers who are PR pros, the conversation might actually have an affect over the long term. We have to individually reject the message, as well as the messengers to solve the problem. Brand the worst-practices with a scarlet A, and don't let them sit with you at lunch! After all, no one likes being banished to the geek table.
Strumpette:
It is only natural that you would despair. You are pushing the edge so far that it is redefining the boundaries. It's lonely out there. You force issues we would rather forget. And you do it with artistry that escapes most of us. We'd really be lost without you.
Wow, Mandy --
And I thought we were friends, possibly kindred spirits? Just two working girls, with a common love of PR. Have you heard the one about the punishment not fitting the crime? Minx? At first glance I thought you were comparing me to a tail-less cat, but you said minx (a "pert girl;" a "wanton woman") -- and shameless to boot! FYI -- I'll take the first minx definition, if I get choice, and/or if you're having a good day and want to throw a bone to your PR gal pal in Denver. But Crap? Low? F#&%ed-up? Talk about Arrrrgh! That's Arrrrgh to the tenth power, girlfriend, in my humble opinion. Just a few facts please, in personal defense, from your recent Strumpette awardee: Since Absolutely PR launched the "Maggie Chamberlin Holben" campaign in 2002, we've had these nine positive placements: Denver Business Journal, 9News, Discover's Inside Biz newsletter -- Public Relations issue, 850 KOA, Denver Post, Boulder Daily Camera, Colorado Daily, Rocky Mountain News and Home Office Weekly. Now, thanks to you Mandy, there's this rather negative, hyper-emotional cyber ink from you (in your widely popular PR industry journal) -- complete with the F-word (albeit used as a quasi-acceptable adjective) and mention in the same ranting column with an icky porn vendor! Yeaks? I really did rub your fur the wrong way -- scary. Standing back, however, and despite your ongoing admonishments, ridicule and unmerciful teasing, I still see a whole lot more on the positive side for the Maggie Holben campaign, than negative. Could I appeal for your mercy? Mercy for a communications colleague just trying to make a living out in the cold, cruel world? Maybe even one day Absolutely PR will qualify for one of those puff-pieces that you might write on a good day in the big city? Something to strive for, I believe. You truly set the bar high. As I thought about closing this posting, I considered quoting the late Mae West when her boyfriend, Ernie, was complaining about her tightness and flatness with the quip, "Strumpette, get off my back!" But, I know you're really only trying to do good for PR and I don't want to be mean-spirited. So, Mandy, isn't it time we turn the corner and walk down the path of friendship together? Please, pretty please? I really think it's truce time for us. Your admirer, Mags (and I don't let everybody call me that) Holben Denver, Colorado Add Comment
|
That's it. I’ve had it. I quit!!
One of the great things about blogging is that your can stretch deadlines! Better late than never, here are my top five posts for last week. 1. The Bad Pitch Blog warns against pay-for-play opportunities. I’ve run into several of these operatio...
Tracked: Feb 26, 06:19